Most Practical Old Fashioned Alarm Clock
The research
- Why you should trust us
- A budget digital alarm with a large face: DreamSky Compact Digital Warning Clock
- A merely "smart plenty" clock: Lenovo Smart Clock Essential
- A unique and informative digital alarm clock: Oct17 Wooden Alert Clock
- A bones but loud digital alarm clock: RCA RCD30
- An unalarming bedside companion: Loftie Alert Clock
- Best sunlight alarm clock: Philips SmartSleep Wake-Upwardly Light HF3520
- A classic wooden alarm clock: Lemnos Riki Alarm Clock
- How nosotros picked and tested
- What to look forward to
- Notable competition
- The competition
Why you should trust the states
I'chiliad a writer at Pattern Milk, and since 2006 I've been writing about dwelling design for a multitude of blueprint-focused outlets, including Apartment Therapy, Lonny, Metropolis, and Blueprint Sponge. I've too written several guides here at Wirecutter, including on bedside lamps, flooring lamps, bed frames, and patio piece of furniture. Previously, as an industrial designer, I designed children'south toys and furniture, and this allowed me to learn the ins and outs of mass-market product blueprint—from formulation to manufacturing. I take an uncanny ability to wake approximately i minute before any alarm, merely I'g still paranoid enough to set i every bit a fill-in.
A budget digital alarm with a large face: DreamSky Compact Digital Alert Clock
Our selection
Best for: Those who desire a large digital display, want to charge devices overnight via USB, and don't mind a plug-in model.
Why it's great: If you lot're looking for an alarm clock that does a lot on the inexpensive, the DreamSky Compact Digital Alarm Clock is both an alert clock and a USB charging station. Something that really stood out with this model, versus other clocks nosotros tested: The DreamSky has an enormous digital brandish (each number is two inches alpine) that stretches beyond the entire front end of the clock. Although I'k nearsighted, with basically mole-like eyesight, I could read this clock conspicuously from a distance—without wearing glasses or contacts.
Some digital alarm clocks nosotros tested—specifically those with lots of extra features and controls, such every bit the Philips Wake-Up Low-cal—required a detailed review of manuals to become them up and running. The DreamSky, on the other manus, was plug and play: The clock was easy and intuitive to set up and accommodate, with clearly labeled buttons for time and warning and two physical dials for volume control and display effulgence. The DreamSky was the just clock we tested that had such a wide range of customization options—it'due south uncomplicated to literally dial in your personal preferences. The snooze button isn't a physical push, just there's a bear upon-sensitive surface that shushes the warning in ix-infinitesimal increments.
If y'all're picky about colors, you'll like that this DreamSky model offers 7 color variations, with unlike finishes and brandish hues to choose from. There's also a similar DreamSky model that includes a digital FM radio and a three.5-millimeter headphone jack.
You should know that this alarm clock is non fully battery-operated—two backup AAA batteries are responsible only for keeping time and alarm settings, in example of a power outage. There are two USB ports in the dorsum—i to accuse most mobile devices with five V output and the other to power the clock via USB (or you can plug directly into the wall).
Flaws but not dealbreakers: The DreamSky logo emblazoned at the meridian (underneath the snooze button) is downright ugly. The plastic example and buttons experience every bit like what you'd await from a $20 device. The batteries protect only time and warning settings, in case of a power outage; for a full display, you have to plug in the clock or keep it connected via USB cablevision.
Materials: plastic
Finishes/colors: blackness case available with green, orange, red, white, or blue digits; white example available with white or bluish digits
Dimensions: 5.8 by 2.9 by 2.seven inches
Power: plug adapter
A just "smart enough" clock: Lenovo Smart Clock Essential
Our selection
Best for: Anyone looking for a compact digital alarm clock that offers time, day, and weather info at a glance, and those who prefer using voice controls over concrete buttons.
Why it'due south peachy: Lenovo offers two Smart Clocks, the Lenovo Smart Clock and its cheaper sibling, the Lenovo Smart Clock Essential. We liked the smaller and more affordable of the ii because its options are true to its name—Essential—with fourth dimension, atmospheric condition, and mean solar day easily viewed at a glance across its 4.5-inch auto-brightness-adjusting LED brandish.
About everything this alarm clock can do is hidden, accessed using its congenital-in Google Assistant voice controls or with the Google Home app. Even though the clock is outfitted with four evenly distributed buttons—for book, turning on music, and the alarm settings—they are obscured from view due to the angled wedge blueprint. Unless you're looking at them from above, the buttons are discernible but by affect, and I often fumbled at dark or in the early on morn while trying to plough on music or adjust the volume. There'due south also a tap at the tiptop to enable the snooze characteristic, but it sometimes required some other touch to annals. To set the alert, adjust the volume, or turn on the night-light, it was always much easier to summon help with a "hey, Google …" instead. Fortunately, the clock'southward two microphones (one in the front end, the other in the back) are very sensitive and able to discern commands, even when nosotros used a hushed volume at night. And though the clock's unmarried-speaker output can be a flake tinny for playing music, it can get surprisingly loud and is but fine for alarm tones and answering Google Assistant prompts.
The clock'southward meaty size is ideal for anyone with limited infinite. Withal, Lenovo included a USB ii.0 Type-A port in the back for charging devices (albeit at a tedious rate, which is all-time for overnight charging). There's too an oval-shaped dark-light in the back. Just the output is fairly dim, even at the brightest setting, and then it'due south best used as an ambient light to assistance y'all observe your style in the dark.
Flaws but not dealbreakers: The clock'south physical buttons brand a satisfying click when pressed. But because of their angled pitch, they're small and hard to discern. The tap-to-snooze characteristic can be finicky.
Materials: polycarbonate and material cover
Finishes/colors: gray
Dimensions: ii.51 by 3.26 past four.51 inches
Power: Plug-in
A unique and informative digital alarm clock: Oct17 Wooden Alert Clock
Our selection
All-time for: Those who prefer the look of wood over plastic and who value unfussy contemporary design—as well as those who desire an alarm clock that displays the time, date, temperature, and humidity at a glance.
Why it'southward great: The Oct17's triangular-shaped forest torso looks much nicer than 1 might expect from a budget clock. In fact, it's more attractive than many pricier clock options we considered. (Information technology'southward besides the only clock we constitute that'southward virtually impossible to tip over.) This model is very affordable, and nevertheless compared with the cheap feel of the DreamSky and Capello warning clocks, the Oct17 seems upscale. The clock's forest-grain terminate has a slap-up feel, and its cool "now y'all see me, now yous don't" LED display shines from beneath its veneer.
The Oct17 displays more information at a glance than whatever other clock we recommend, showing the time and engagement (alternating) aslope the temperature and humidity level—all without requiring an cyberspace connexion. If yous're bothered by ambient light glowing from your clock, the Oct17 has three brightness settings. And it's the only brandish we plant that you tin gear up to turn off completely after 10 seconds. But when you lot demand to know the time again, a clap of the hands or a tap on the front face will reawaken the clock for x seconds.
If you don't wake at the same fourth dimension each mean solar day, this is the digital alert clock for you: It has three separate alarms, including one you tin can set to skip on weekends (to allow for sleeping in).
Flaws merely non dealbreakers: Navigating the clock'due south mode settings and feature adjustments proved unintuitive, requiring more than button presses than a Street Fighter move combination.
Materials: MDF and wood veneer
Finishes/colors: brown, black, bamboo, and white finishes
Dimensions: 3.1 by three.1 by v.9 inches
Power: USB cable (included), four AAA batteries (non included) for emergency power fill-in
A basic simply loud digital alarm clock: RCA RCD30
Our pick
All-time for: Anyone who doesn't desire to spend a lot of money, prefers a huge digital brandish, and is only looking for the basics to be done right.
Why it's great: The RCA RCD30 is an affordable digital alarm clock with a bright display, an easy-to-use button layout, and an alert loud plenty to wake even heavy sleepers. It's too the least expensive model we tested, making it an like shooting fish in a barrel choice when you lot demand something cheap and undecayed, similar for a guest room or a vacation rental.
The RCA is a basic unit, but information technology has all yous really need in an alert clock. Information technology'southward one of the smallest clocks we considered, so it won't accept up much room on your nightstand. But information technology'due south also like shooting fish in a barrel to read, with a 3.75-by-one.4-inch illuminated display that's visible in daylight and at dark from at least 20 feet away. The large display size is a boon for people who wear spectacles because in that location'south no need to bollix for them in society to check the time. If a big display keeps you up at night, know that the RCD30 does offer a dimmer setting.
The no-frills RCA is besides easier to utilise than other, more than complicated clocks nosotros tested. Information technology has a large snooze push button beyond the superlative, so you can commonly hit it without much trouble. On the back, there are iii switches: one for setting the time and alarm, one for dimming the forepart display, and ane for turning the alarm on and off. The alarm emits a loud, constant beep that can be heard from at least 20 anxiety abroad. That wake-up call continues until you shut off the alarm or hit snooze (which provides an extra nine minutes of slumber every time you press it, for well over an hour).
The RCD30 besides comes with the option for fill-in via a 9-volt bombardment, so you won't lose your settings if the ability goes out at 2 a.m. Every bit with well-nigh of the warning clocks we tested, when the RCD30 is using only battery ability, information technology volition not display the fourth dimension, but the alarm will all the same go off.
Flaws simply not dealbreakers: A few of the alarm clocks we reviewed have up and downwards buttons for setting the time. The RCA does non. The infinitesimal and hour buttons go in merely one direction, so if y'all get distracted while setting the fourth dimension and go besides far, you'll demand to wheel through over again. This is non unique to the RCA, though; setting the alert on the Alessi Optic 02 B presented a similarly frustrating, "careful, don't miss it" experience.
Materials: plastic
Finishes/colors: black, white
Dimensions: five by 4 past 6 inches
Ability: AC plug-in
An unalarming bedside companion: Loftie Alert Clock
Our pick
Loftie
An unalarming and smarter bedside companion
This was one of the least sleep-disruptive digital alarm clocks nosotros tested. Whether information technology'due south the night-light, the snooze push, or the sound of the alarm tones, every particular feels like it's been refined to reinforce a state of at-home.
Best for: Those who believe in the minimalist ethos of "less, just better," and people who relish falling asleep or waking up to ambience music and nature sounds.
Why information technology's great: The Loftie can fool you lot into thinking you're waking up of your ain accord every forenoon, rather than being forcibly annoyed out of bed. Of all the alert clocks we tested, the clock's selection of five ambience compositions best induced the sensation of arising aslope the natural cues of the forenoon—sounds of birds, ambient tones, morning time temple bells. After nine minutes, the Loftie follows up the kickoff alarm with an e'er-then-slightly more-insistent "get up" chime. (After first using the Loftie, I wrote downwards that "I felt like I had arisen to a morning directed past Terrence Malick, all wistful mood and relaxing stillness.") In that location's the option to set up different alarms scheduled for different days of the calendar week, too equally a multitude of alarms you could set as reminders throughout the mean solar day—to go upward occasionally, exercise, or walk the dog, amongst other everyday tasks.
The Loftie is also designed to aid owners relax and autumn comatose. It includes a variety of background-noise generators (white, dark-brown, pink, and and so forth), meditation/breathwork soundscapes, and even a podcast called Snoozecast. Any sound can be programmed to exist activated or turned off with the printing of a push button, and this made the Loftie easy to use when the heavy blanket of unconsciousness began to take over at dark.
Of clocks nosotros've tested, this one'southward display isn't the largest or the brightest. Just it's articulate, and information technology automatically sets the time once connected to a Wi-Fi network. We too liked the clock'south all-black outside (it comes in a white and black choice, too), which is free of distracting lights or branding. There's an adjustable night-light hidden at the base of operations that's easily turned on and off, using the big button on top of the clock (it as well works every bit the snooze button). You lot won't be able to read using the light, but it's brilliant enough for when you're fumbling for your glasses or going to the bathroom in the heart of the night. The two other buttons are for setting the alarm, accessing brightness and volume settings, setting the elapsing of the sleep timer, and choosing warning tones. The Loftie isn't "smart" like other smart alarm clocks, in that you won't be served the news or the weather with the assist of a vocalism banana. Simply on a regular basis this clock can become boosted features delivered via Wi-Fi updates. For instance, nosotros discovered ane nighttime that there were a few more soothing classical compositions to wake up to than we'd had the twenty-four hour period before and that alarm-scheduling options had been expanded. The developers recently added Bluetooth speaker functionality and are promising Spotify connectivity and boosted sounds every bit features that are "coming soon." We'll update this guide when—and if—these features appear.
Flaws but not dealbreakers: The Loftie was originally $165 when we showtime tested it simply the price has now been lowered to $150. We still think it's a pretty penny to pay for whatsoever device, let alone an warning clock with a purposely edited choice of features. The numerical brandish is legible up close, only it's slightly dimmer when viewed off-center. And, for nearsighted sleepers like u.s.a., we wish there were an choice to increase the display size.
Materials: polycarbonate
Finishes/colors: black (with an option for black or white emphasis colors)
Dimensions: 2.75 past 6.5 by 2.75 inches
Ability: plug-in (USB-C adapter)
All-time sunlight alarm clock: Philips SmartSleep Wake-Up Light HF3520
Our option
All-time for: Anyone who hates existence jolted awake each forenoon with a wailing alarm, and those who prefer easing into consciousness with increasing luminosity.
Why it's keen: A top option in our guide to sunrise alarm clocks, the Philips SmartSleep Wake-Up Calorie-free HF3520 is even so our favorite sunrise alarm clock for anyone who hates being woken abruptly. Over the span of 30 minutes, the luminous LED orb produces a convincing simulation of dawn or dusk. It provides a kinder, gentler wake-up than any other alarm we recommend, and it's the simply clock we tested that can help lull you to sleep at nighttime. The Wake-Up Low-cal also includes more than alarm options than most clocks we tried, with five nature-themed tones, along with a built-in FM tuner and a backup alarm. (However, navigating the clock's touch surface and icon-based menu system isn't very intuitive, and non ever responsive.) Our favorite setting was a combination of the faux sunlight paired with the convincing sounds of cheerful chirping birds.
Nosotros also institute the clock'south light sufficiently bright enough to work as a decent reading lamp, making the Wake-Upwards the merely clock we recommend that can do so. At viii inches wide, this model takes upward a lot more room on the nightstand than other clocks we tested. But when you think of the Wake-Up as a combination alarm clock and bedside lamp, information technology presents a pretty efficient utilize of space.
Flaws simply non dealbreakers: Despite the Wake-Up Calorie-free's overall size, its numerical digital brandish is less than an inch tall and and so not equally like shooting fish in a barrel to read as those of the other clocks we tried (particularly with its light at full brightness). The secondary gear up of tactile buttons across the unit's top are more intuitive to utilise than the icons on the clock's display, but they're small and all the same size, then information technology's easy to press the wrong push. The FM radio is a plus, but because that the clock is our 2nd-nigh-expensive pick, the silver-dollar-sized rear-facing speaker is tinny and disappointing. The LED bulb is rated to last 7 years with regular use. But it cannot exist replaced, so over time the clock could lose its well-nigh distinguishing characteristic.
Materials: polycarbonate
Finishes/colors: white
Dimensions: 8 by 3 past 3 inches
Power: DC ability plug with eight-60 minutes power backup
A archetype wooden alarm clock: Lemnos Riki Alert Clock
Our pick
Lemnos Riki Alarm Clock
A handsome, classic clock
The Riki is an analog clock that'south easy to read and to set (with i of the virtually pleasant alarms that will all the same wake you upward). It's ideal for low-cal sleepers who want to banish electronic distractions from the chamber.
Best for: Pattern enthusiasts, or anyone looking to ditch their smartphone for an uncomplicated, completely silent, easy-to-employ classic alarm clock.
Why it's slap-up: If you want a dependable alert clock with a timeless analog pattern that's dead silent and easy to apply, the Lemnos Riki checks all of those boxes. The but alarm clock amidst our picks with a pattern-honor pedigree, the sedate beechwood Riki was designed past Japanese modernist Riki Watanabe, whose work was known for beingness elementary yet functional. The Riki'south prominent face has one-half-inch-tall numerals and large hour and infinitesimal arms, so information technology'southward piece of cake to read—even in dim calorie-free and from a distance. The clock'due south sole button consolidates the low-cal and snooze functions (doling out extra sleep in four-minute increments), and nosotros found information technology effortless to use, fifty-fifty with our eyes closed. When y'all press the push, the clock illuminates merely plenty to make the confront legible (a big plus for those of u.s. who like to peek at the time earlier nosotros accept whatever existent intention of waking upward). The brightness level seemed more akin to candlelight than to the intrusive modern glare produced by the LED- or LCD-backlit displays on other clocks we tested. Even the side by side-dimmest dark-light (on the Marathon Analog Desk-bound Alert Clock with Auto-Night Light) seemed much too bright afterwards we'd acclimated to the Riki's tranquil illumination.
Although it looks perfectly round, the clock really has a subtle indentation on its base that keeps it from rolling away—and from moving when brushed or bumped. And because this clock is battery-operated (it needs only a unmarried AA battery), there are no cords to worry nearly. In addition to its snooze push, the straightforward Riki has but iii controls: an on/off switch for the alarm and two dial knobs to set the time and the warning.
If the tick-tock of some clocks' mechanical motility tends to continue you awake, rest assured that this clock is completely silent—something nosotros can't say most the percussive passing of time produced by the Alessi Optic 02 B or the faint bzzzz emanating from the Marathon Analog Desk Alert Clock with Auto-Dark Light. The simply sound the Riki makes comes from its alarm, which is loud enough to wake you without being annoying.
Flaws but not dealbreakers: The Riki isn't cheap, and it's gone upwardly a fleck in price since we commencement tested it. Even though this clock is nonetheless bachelor on Amazon and at various other retailers, the Lemnos site currently lists the Riki every bit "archived," so we're investigating whether it may have been discontinued permanently. We will update this guide as soon as we know more.
Setting the Riki's warning to a specific 60 minutes is fairly simple to do, but setting information technology to an exact minute is more than of an estimate, due to the clock's dial face. The ABS resin snooze-and-light button matches the color of the beechwood clock case, but it isn't made of forest.
Materials: beechwood, ABS resin, glass
Finishes/colors: natural, brown, white, gray
Dimensions: four.3 past 4.v past ii.two inches
Power: ane AA battery
How we picked and tested
Alarm clocks may seem a chip old-fashioned, since everyone and their grandmother now uses a phone as an alert. A search for "alarm clock" on Amazon returns a paltry seven pages of models to choose from, many only minutely different from the next (and most so ugly that the idea of sleeping nigh them is enough to induce mild insomnia).
Just there are yet some corking options bachelor today, and here are the features we looked for in an ideal alarm clock:
- Piece of cake to read: Whether it has hands or a digital brandish, a clock should be legible at a glance, even without contacts or eyeglasses.
- Produces a pleasant alarm tone: The ideal alert will wake you lot up without creating a jarring effect. Nosotros favored models with pleasant tones and the option to change them based on personal preference.
- Dimmable: A persistent, noticeable bright low-cal tin be a detriment to falling asleep. Nosotros highly recommend a clock with the choice of manually or automatically dimming the display.
- Compact and stable: A good alarm clock has a low center of gravity and sufficient weight to counter the clumsy hands of the half-awake.
- Uncomplicated to set: Accessing alarm on/off settings or adjusting features like snooze, brightness, and alarm volume shouldn't require a PhD or a YouTube tutorial.
- Unobtrusive: An alarm clock should not be the first thing you notice in a bedroom—perhaps it should even be the last. Leave the statement pieces to the living room.
- Extra features: Radio, USB ports, Bluetooth and internet connectivity, multiple alarms, alarm sound and tone options, and a backup battery are all welcome (just non necessary).
In 2018, after reading through client reviews on Amazon and other retailers—and focusing particularly on the qualities listed to a higher place—we called in the ten well-nigh promising alarm clocks. We used each clock for a few days and nights. In 2021, nosotros once more scoured retailers and called in four more alarm clocks to test. We tested each model in our bedrooms, with the warning prepare half an hour earlier than our usual wake-up time, to ensure the clock's alert tone was responsible for breaking our usual sleep cycle as well as to allow us to use each clock'south snooze part while still groggy. We also kept an eye out for cosmetic defects, and nosotros inspected the immovability of materials and construction, imagining the litany of abuse an alarm clock may have to endure over its lifetime. Bated from the largest clock (the Philips Wake-Up Light), our picks are small; they should fit on almost nightstands and won't slide or knock over hands.
What to look forrad to
Nosotros're keeping an eye on the OneClock, a supposedly congenital-to-final-a-lifetime analog alarm clock that is in the procedure of getting crowdfunded on Indiegogo. But with an estimated $350 retail price, it's definitely not cheap. We won't officially review it until the clock is fully available to the public, merely a pre-production sample we saw seemed promising. We'll update this guide when we take more information. We're also going to wait at the Repeat Dot with clock in our next round of testing, to see how it compares to the Lenovo Smart Clock Essential.
Notable competition
Sangean RCR-5
Practiced for: People who want a basic and affordable AM/FM radio clock.
If you're looking for a solid alarm clock that'southward outfitted with essential features, this back-to-basics dual alarm clock–radio is less than $50. The Sangean scores solidly online with owners, but nosotros found the clock's cheap, sleeky plastic finish and overly conspicuous logo distracting and reminiscent of models found on drugstore electronics shelves. It made us capeesh the similarly priced Lenovo Smart Clock Essential'south tasteful simplicity that much more than.
Lenovo Smart Clock
Expert for: Someone who wants a smart alarm with a colour screen.
The Lenovo Smart Clock is simply barely larger than its more affordable, monochromatic, not-impact Essential analogue. Merely the Smart Clock adds a punchy, full-color touchscreen brandish with a choice of user-customizable faces and more than alarm options than the Essential, but with the same Google Assistant hatful of tricks. We think the introduction of another bright color screen in the sleeping accommodation isn't a great idea, and the few extras the Smart Clock adds do not really justify its price.
The competition
Marathon Analog Desk-bound Warning Clock with Car-Night Light: The Marathon has many corking features. In addition to its compact design (the clock measures iii.5 inches wide by one.5 inches deep), the Marathon features a sensor night-light, dead-quiet motility, a conspicuously marked warning and snooze buttons, and a low-glow light that's similar to (simply not quite every bit skilful as) the one on the Riki. Its one and only shortcoming was legibility: The clock'southward printed numerals were small and hard to read at a glance. Nosotros'd all the same recommend it if y'all desire a bombardment-operated alarm clock that'south easy to throw in your luggage.
Lexon Flip On/Off Alert Clock: (Of notation: This clock has now been replaced by the Lexon Flip Plus; the size hasn't changed, however.) The Lexon Flip is fun to use and has a novel design that works well: To turn the alarm on or off, you flip the entire clock over, instead of pressing a button or a switch. Each side is clearly marked, with "on" written across the clock'due south rubber coating on ane side and "off" written beyond the other side. The Flip (which is nearly impossible to tip over) takes up little infinite, but its small size besides means it isn't every bit legible as we'd like for an everyday alarm clock. Its LCD display is hard to run across in standby mode, and it'due south like shooting fish in a barrel to read only with the backlight on. Too, its high-pitched digital tone is constructive yet annoying.
MoMA Alume Cube Clock: We liked the Alume for its compact, 2.75-inch minimalist argent-cube design. It should fit on any surface with enough of room to spare, displaying the time, date, and temperature with a snap of the fingers or a tap on its top. Where the clock comes upward short: the absenteeism of snooze or dimming options (the display turns completely off between snaps or taps) with an LED display that glows a chip too cold and bright for tired or still-waking optics. If you practise like this design, there are several knockoffs—with similar features—for a lot less.
Capello Round Time Tabular array Clock: The Capello is a pocket-sized and lightweight plug-in alarm clock with an like shooting fish in a barrel-to-read LED display and a stylish gray-fabric front. A USB port in the back works great for overnight charging, but the listed "option to plug in your telephone so you lot tin listen to music" didn't really work for us (with an iPhone). And the clock's lightweight plastic construction made information technology piece of cake to knock over. The snooze button isn't a real button—touches or lite taps won't register. Snoozing the alarm requires a firm, palm-down press across the entire clock. If you're sensitive to light, you should notation that even at the dimmest of this clock's iii settings, the LED display was distracting. Nosotros eventually had to plow information technology face-down.
Alessi Optic 02 B Warning Clock: This at present-discontinued model from Alessi was an instance of high design beingness hampered past low-quality features. This clock was too audible to be a peaceful bedside companion, producing a tick-tock sound so loud that it bothered usa even when we were in the next room. No doubt, the Italian space-historic period design is eye-communicable, but having this clock virtually the bed made the passing of fourth dimension a torturous, second-by-second affair. And we found its plastic construction flimsy, with tiny and hard-to-set up dial controls that had more in common with a cheap, drugstore alarm clock than something sold for many times the price.
0 Response to "Most Practical Old Fashioned Alarm Clock"
Post a Comment